Sunday, January 1, 2017

2016 Cybils Shortlist Reading Challenge

Cybils-Logo-2016-Round-Sm

Happy New Year! The Cybils are Posted! That means it's time to start my first challenge --  my personal Cybils Shortlist Challenge!

I haven't actually finished last year's list yet, due to a reading collapse in December, although I had all the books. I'll finish ticking them off as I work through this years list. Endless optimism from me! I also note that I managed to read exactly zero of the nominees this year, which means that nothing I nominated made the cut.

I'm especially looking forward to the new audio category. I'm not sure if I should read the book that appears in as both an audio and a text choice, though, except that Grace Lin's illustrations definitely enhance the reading. Again, I'm listing the entries in reverse order, to encourage me to start with the longer ones.

Young Adult Speculative Fiction: 





  1. Illuminae  by Amie Kaufman. I was completely unprepared for this book -- I didn't read the jacket copy and thought it would be a spy thing with hidden societies. I was very pleased to find myself instead on a battered space battleship fleeing a murderous corporate dreadnaught. The kids themselves were rather thin, but they were so busy fighting with the enemy, the authorities, the computer system, and each other that I didn't have time to notice. The various formats of the books kept things interesting as well. Fun read that I recommend to my teens.
  2. Still Life with Tornado by A.S. King. This started slowly but ending up keeping me turning pages. I'm a bit jaded by books about teen artists, which explains my reluctance to commit, but strangely the magic realism of the other Sarahs led me in. I did feel that it became a bit of an issue book -- bad teachers, school bullying, dangers of social media, home issues and wished that only a few of these menaced our protagonist but maybe then the magic resolutions wouldn't have worked.
  3. The Door at the Crossroads by Zetta Elliott. I liked parts of this very much -- Judah's life in slavery was harrowing, and his ruthless belief that he was free sustained him through torture and violence. The descriptions of the other slaves and owners also seemed nuanced and emotionally real. But the pieces didn't all seem to hold together; the characters seemed to change between sections of the book in ways unrelated to their experiences.
  4. Labyrinth Lost (Brooklyn Brujas) by Zoraida Cordova. Again there were interesting parts -- the characters and the setting were great. But I found the main character's useless guilt wearisome; if you don't know how to do something and the people who could help you ignore you, then it's not surprising when it goes wrong. And I found her passivity and lack of competence also aggravating because it seemed like the author was trying to avoid having a girl be too strong. She's the long awaited hero -- she can notice her strengths and use them without pretending she doesn't know what she's doing! This is probably more my problem than any kids, though. My son liked this.

  5. The Keeper of the Mist by Rachel Neumeier
    Alfred A. Knopf Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: Charlotte

    This Savage Song (Monsters of Verity) by Victoria Schwab
    Greenwillow Books
    Nominated by: Whinkz

    When the Moon was Ours: A Novel by Anna-Marie McLemore
    Thomas Dunne Books
    Nominated by: Kelly Jensen

    Young Adult Fiction 

    A Study in Charlotte (Charlotte Holmes Novel)by Brittany Cavallaro
    Katherine Tegen Books
    Nominated by: Stephanie Burgis

    Beastby Brie Spangler
    Alfred A. Knopf Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: Kim Baccellia

    Runby Kody Keplinger
    Scholastic Press
    Nominated by: Cecilia Cackley

    Salt to the Seaby Ruta Sepetys
    Philomel
    Nominated by: Compass Book Ratings

    The Serpent Kingby Jeff Zentner
    Crown Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: Esther Braithwaite

    The Weight of Zeroby Karen Fortunati
    Delacorte Press Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: MarisaR

    This Is Where It Ends by Marieke Nijkamp (2016-01-05)by Marieke Nijkamp
    Sourcebooks Fire
    Nominated by: Katharine Manning


    Young Adult Graphic Novels






    1. Ms. Marvel Vol. 5: Super Famous by G. Willow Wilson. I didn't enjoy this one as much as the previous volumes; I think I like my ratio of heroics to normal problems to skew more towards the hero stuff. The center this time seemed the problems anyone could have. I realize that I'm wrong, but that's how I roll.
    Dare to Disappoint: Growing Up in Turkey by Ozge Samanci
    Farrar, Straus & Giroux
    Nominated by: Linda Baie

    Faith Volume 1: Hollywood and Vine by Jody Houser
    Valiant books
    Nominated by: Tiffa

    Lucky Penny by Ananth Hirsh & Yuko Ota
    Oni Press
    Publisher/ Author Submission

    March: Book Three by John Lewis
    Top Shelf Productions
    Nominated by: Becky L.

    Monstress Volume 1: Awakening by Marjorie Liu
    image comics
    Nominated by: Charlotte

    Trashed by Derf Backderf
    Harry N Abrams
    Nominated by: Gary Anderson


    Middle Grade / Young Adult Non-fiction 

    Middle Grade: 
    Bubonic Panic: When Plague Invaded Americaby Gail Jarrow
    Calkins Creek Books
    Nominated by: Deb Nance at Readerbuzz

    Fashion Rebels: Style Icons Who Changed the World through Fashionby Carlyn Cerniglia Beccia
    Aladdin
    Nominated by: Becky L.

    Sachiko: A Nagasaki Bomb Survivor’s Storyby Caren Stelson
    Carolrhoda Books
    Nominated by: Amanda Snow

    This Land Is Our Land: A History of American Immigrationby Linda Barret Osborne
    Harry N Abrams
    Nominated by: VikingAcademy

    Young Adult:






    1. Every Falling Star: The True Story of How I Survived and Escaped North Koreaby Sungju Lee. This powerful story of a child forced to survive on his own reminded me of some of the WWII fiction I read as a kid, except that the realism and nonfiction level made things grimmer. I alternated between admiration for the independence and leadership Sungju displayed and horror at the grim choices and dehumanizing situations he found himself making.
    2. Blood, Bullets, and Bones: The Story of Forensic Science from Sherlock Holmes to DNA by Bridget Heos. The individual chapters had plenty of fun facts about how authorities figured out who killed the dead bodies that turn up, but it didn't real gel together as a complete book. 
    Blood Brother: Jonathan Daniels and His Sacrifice for Civil Rightsby Rich Wallace
    Calkins Creek Books
    Nominated by: Sherry Early

    The Borden Murders: Lizzie Borden and the Trial of the Centuryby Sarah Miller
    Schwartz and Wade Books
    Nominated by: Sara Ralph

    Middle Grade Fiction 

    Full of Beansby Jennifer L. Holm
    Random House Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: PragmaticMom

    Ghost (Track)by Jason Reynolds
    Atheneum Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: Abby Johnson

    In the Footsteps of Crazy Horseby Joseph Marshall
    Amulet
    Nominated by: Sussu Leclerc

    Ms. Bixby’s Last Dayby John David Anderson
    Walden Pond Press
    Nominated by: Brenda

    Save Me a Seatby Sarah Weeks
    Publisher not defined
    Nominated by: Maria Gianferrari

    Slackerby Gordon Korman
    Scholastic
    Nominated by: Amy

    Some Kind of Happinessby Claire Legrand
    Simon & Schuster
    Nominated by: CDwivedi

    Poetry


    Bookedby Kwame Alexander
    HMH Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: PragmaticMom

    Fresh Deliciousby Irene Latham
    Wordsong
    Nominated by: Linda Baie

    Garvey’s Choiceby Nikki Grimes
    Wordsong
    Nominated by: MissRumphius

    Guess Who, Haikuby Deanna Caswell
    Harry N Abrams
    Nominated by: Kortney Garrison

    The Last Fifth Grade of Emerson Elementaryby Laura Shovan
    Wendy Lamb Books
    Nominated by: Adrienne Gillespie

    When Green Becomes Tomatoes: Poems for All Seasonsby Julie Fogliano
    Roaring Brook Press
    Nominated by: Sara Ralph


    Board Books: 





  6. Dinosaur Dance! by Sandra Boynton. Standard Boynton -- fun pictures, fun words, faintly sophisticated and companionable. I wanted a few more rhymes.
  7. Cuauhtemoc: Shapes/Formas (English and Spanish Edition) by Patty Rodriguez. The colors seemed gently muted, which is not what I look for in a baby book. The pages were pleasant, shape and word on one side and an illustration on the other, but often the illustration seemed a bit subtle for the audience, such as a snake inside a shape that grabs the interest from the named word.
  8. Cityblock (Alphablock)by Christopher Franceschelli
    Harry N Abrams
    Nominated by: Becky L. (not at KCLS, spl)

    Follow the Yarn: A Book of Colorsby Emily Sper
    Jump Press
    Nominated by: ediew (not at kcls, spl)

    LOOK, LOOK AGAINby Agnese Baruzzi
    Minedition
    Publisher/ Author Submission (not at kcls, spl)


    Fiction Picture Books:(Done)


    1. A Hungry Lion, or A Dwindling Assortment of Animals by Lucy Ruth Cummins
    2. There’s a Bear on My Chair by Ross Collins
    3. Ida, Always by Caron Levis
    4. The Night Gardener by Terry and Eric Fan 
    5. One Day in the Eucalyptus, Eucalyptus Tree by Daniel Bernstrom
    6. Strictly No Elephants by Lisa Mantchev
    7. They All Saw a Cat by Brendan Wenzel

    Elementary / Middle Grade Speculative Fiction

    Shadow Magicby Joshua Khan
    Disney-Hyperion
    Nominated by: Sussu Leclerc
    The Evil Wizard Smallboneby Delia Sherman
    Candlewick Press
    Nominated by: Lizjonesbooks

    The Firefly Codeby Megan Frazer Blakemore
    Bloomsbury USA
    Nominated by: Sarah Sammis

    The Goblin’s Puzzle: Being the Adventures of a Boy with No Name and Two Girls Called Aliceby Andrew Chilton
    Alfred A. Knopf Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: E.B.
    The Memory Thiefby Bryce Moore
    Adaptive Books
    Nominated by: Kristen

    The Voyage to Magical Northby Claire Fayers
    Henry Holt
    Nominated by: Sheila Ruth

    When the Sea Turned to Silverby Grace Lin
    Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
    Nominated by: PragmaticMom


    Elementary / Middle Grade Graphic Novels
    1. The Wolves of Currumpaw by William GrillTragic and heartbreaking yet very compelling. The simplistic artwork didn't grab but also didn't repel me. I didn't know the story so I kept hoping feebly for a miracle, knowing it wasn't coming. The oversized pages enhanced the experience.
    2. Lowriders to the Center of the Earth (Book 2) (Lowriders in Space) by Cathy Camper. Three animal friends and their fancy car rescue their cat from the underworld, with a lot of Spanglish and adventures along the way. The red colors make things seem energetic and alert, and the Spanish words made me feel smart.
    3. Princess Princess Ever After by Katie O’Neill. This was a cute story with many twists on standard fairy tale tropes, as the characters reveal themselves to have additional depth and quirks. The main characters are of course married at the end, but at least they agree to wait until they've reached competence in their careers (warrior and ruler). I think some kids will find the fact that the romantic couple are both princesses fascinating, but it's not such a big deal around here.
    4. Bera the One-Headed Troll by Eric Orchard. A pumpkin farming troll steps up to help a baby, despite the uselessness or active malice of the heroes she appeals to for help. The pictures were finely drawn but rather dark, and my face-blindness for graphics meant that I managed to be confused about who was there even with the sparse characters. Fun enough read  but hard for me.

Compass South (Four Points)by Hope Larson
Farrar, Straus & Giroux
Nominated by: Amy


Mighty Jackby Ben Hatke
First Second Books
Nominated by: Charlotte


The Nameless Cityby Faith Erin Hicks
First Second Books
Nominated by: Compass Book Ratings


Elementary / Juvenile Non-Fiction:

Elementary Non-Fiction: DONE! I picked the winner!

  1. Giant Squid by Candace Fleming and Eric Rohmann. First of all -- GIANT SQUID! So it's starting off on a strong foot. Then I was charmed by the poetic yet informative text, which echoes the majestic beauty of these creatures while educating me on the facts and unknowns surrounding them. The final pages give some dull diagrams, and the fold out spread was not as colorful or dramatic as I might wish, but still a great read for preschoolers or young school kids.
  2. The First Step: How One Girl Put Segregation on Trial by Susan E. Goodman (2016-01-05) by Susan E. Goodman. The narrative of the first pages, where a family in Boston sued (and lost) to have their child attend a school closer to home works as a story and the pictures complement it well. After focusing on this case, the book gives an overview of how segregation was ended in Boston and eventually everywhere, discussing the step-forward and step-backward pace of social justice. It's a child's-eye view of a lesser known historical event and also historical theory -- how societies change in non-linear ways.
  3. Step Right Up: How Doc and Jim Key Taught the World about Kindness by Donna Janell Bowman. Fun story starting with an enslaved child and ending with a rich businessman and his clever horse. I'd heard about Jim the smart horse before so it was fun to get more details, and the illustrations would make this a fun picture book to share or give a young reader. The language was fresh and modern ("enslaved child" rather than "slave" for example).
  4. Finding Winnie: The True Story of the World’s Most Famous Bearby Lindsay Mattick. Frame of a bedtime story keeps the journey of the bear Winnie from Canada to England cosy and heroic. Example of a nonfiction book that works well as a picture book for sharing at bedtime or reading time. Wow, Canadians are sure apple-cheeked!
  5. Pink Is For Blobfish: Discovering the World’s Perfectly Pink Animals (The World of Weird Animals) by Jess Keating. This is a short version of the Strange (etc) Animal book on the other little kid nonfiction list. Each page has a photo of a pink animal, and then we get fun information and a cute drawing about it, along with a standard kartush with it's location, size, endangered status, etc. It's a good book to read with animal-loving kids, especially ones whose attention spans don't last the whole book as each page is distinct.
  6. Plants Can’t Sit Still (Millbrook Picture Books) by Rebecca E. Hirsch. A fun picture book that describes how plants grow in all directions, and then adds in all the ways their seeds get around. It's fun and informative.
  7. Tortuga Squad: Kids Saving Sea Turtles in Costa Rica by Cathleen Burnham. A focus on a single child opened the window to this look at turtle conservation on a small island in Costa Rica. The rescue squad of children makes this interesting to the elementary crowd, but I was left unsure of some science facts (do hatching and egg laying overlap that much? What does evil Poacher Carlos eat when he's not poaching turtles?). I guess I wanted more specifics, either about turtles or about Bianca, the viewpoint child.

Juvenile Non-Fiction: DONE! The winner was my #3, but I still loved it.




  1. The Slowest Book Ever by April Pulley Sayre. This ended up being inspiring. I thought it would be just a random collection of facts about slow things, but it insisted on continually challenging its readers scientifically, curiously, and thoughtfully.
  2. Masters of Disguise: Amazing Animal Tricksters by Rebecca L. Johnson. Bright colors and a good balance between descriptive sections and background science. Good elementary school science book. I needed to know about the spiders who build robot minions.
  3. Some Writer!: The Story of E. B. White by Melissa Sweet. Excellent biography of the children's book writer, including but not focusing on his adult writing and life. The decorations helped build the mood; it really evoked the feeling of reading his books as a child.
  4. Floodwaters and Flames: The 1913 Disaster in Dayton, Ohio by Lois Miner Huey. Interesting tale of the flood, with clear stories told from a variety of viewpoints and photos illustrating each point. Captions indicate the difference between the image and the story, with clear lines showing where the information is coming from. Most people were chosen to show what was happening in various sections of town, although the inclusion of Orville Wright was clearly for his celebrity.
  5. The Inventors of LEGO Toys (Awesome Minds) by Erin Hagar. A good balance between a history of the company and a biography of the founders, with short bursts of information set off by clear and attractive illustrations.
  6. Will’s Words: How William Shakespeare Changed the Way You Talk by Jane Sutcliffe. Detailed pictures that left me wondering if I was missing a Where's Waldo gag (was Shakespeare on every page?) were muted but appealing. I enjoyed the brief text, which used descriptions of the time and theaters in which the plays were held to give examples of words Shakespeare made part of the language, and then on the alternate page described the use of these words. I'm not sure if it would entice readers who weren't already interested in the Bard, though.
  7. Animal Planet Strange, Unusual, Gross & Cool Animals by Charles Ghigna and Animal Planet. This works as a fun picture book, with large pages suitable to share across a lap. The pages vary between big pictures of a single animal and collections of creatures with something shared among them (cool eyes, etc.). I'm not sure how it works as an actual reference book, as there is no real connection between pages.
  8. Easy Reader and Early Chapter Books:
    Easy Readers (done). The winner didn't mesh with mine, but I and my kids have a weird sense of humor.


    1. The Infamous Ratsos (Ratso Brothers) by Kara LaReau. Wow, I thought I would be too cynical for the obvious moral coming along, but instead it won me over. I liked the way the text and pictures complemented each other, and how the stakes of the brothers' dubious plans rose, and even how the dad responded.
    2. Elephant & Piggie Like Reading! We Are Growing! by Laurie Keller and Mo Willems. I liked the cover and the illustrations, and the way that every page of the book worked toward the overall effect. I also liked the humor and the grass personalities, although the lawnmower stressed me out a bit. It looks like a fun chance for a share read, maybe with a crowd of kids.
    3. Elephant & Piggie Like Reading! The Cookie Fiasco by Dan Santat and Mo Willems. Conflict resolution through neurosis and math -- this book was written for me (and my kids). The pictures work perfectly to add to the fun.
    4. Snail and Worm: Three Stories About Two Friends by Tina Kugler. Two quirky friends have gentle adventures that children will relate to and feel slightly smug about. The pictures and text are good, but somehow I didn't fall in love (except with Snail's eyeballs). Maybe I needed a kid next to me?
    5. The Great Antonio by Elise Gravel. I'm still baffled by the difference between nonfiction and Easy Reader. I thought this was a biography of a real person? I know the author makes a few jokes about aliens, but they are clearly marked off from the more factual text, and the author tries to discuss how substantiated the facts she relates are. This was easy to read and fairly engaging.
    6. Rabbit and Robot and Ribbit by Cece Bell. This one was a bit didactic for me -- Rabbit was clearly misbehaving and doomed to learn better, although I thought the penalty was a bit drastic -- Robot was basically in a coma with failing life support for a while. Oh well, no hard feelings.

    Early Chapter Books

    Juana and LucasDory Dory Black SheepThe Not-a-Pig (Mango & Bambang #1)The Princess in Black and the Hungry Bunny Horde (The Princess in Black, #3)Weekends with Max and His Dad
    1. Juana and Lucas, Anna Wilson. Fun story about a girl in Bogota with decided opinions on many things, including learning English in school. The mix of Spanish words reminds us that she is thinking in Spanish, and the final incentive to get her to buckle down and study is endearing. 
    2. Dory Fantasmagory: Dory Dory Black Sheep by Abby Hanlon. Another fun visit with Dory aka Rascal. We see both her real friends and her imaginary ones, and watch her deal with the worry of not being a good reader and the rather archaic ways her teacher and parents deal with it (I speak as the parent of a late reader). It didn't really seem to have a unified whole, although I appreciated that Dory didn't magically start reading even when she decided to start trying. But her friendships stayed strong as did her commitment to her imagination.
    3. Mango & Bambang: The Not-a-Pig (Book One) (Mango & Bambang 1) by Polly Faber. The story was fine, with a mix of fantasy and realism -- tapirs do live in Malaysia, although this one is unusually articulate. But what really charmed me were the illustrations -- pencil with violet touches, the purple bringing to life small details either for fun or the emphasize a plot point. A fun read for a newly independent reader.
    4. The Princess in Black and the Hungry Bunny Horde, Shannon Hale. Fun but a bit disappointing. As expected, the disguised Princess Black and her loyal pony defeat the monsters. Some of the monsters are cute bunnies, but I expected more from that premise than I got.
    5. Weekends with Max and His Dad by Linda Urban. This seemed emotionally rather flat. The chapters are the right size and the text is easy enough, so it works as a early chapter book, but Max has no emotional connection to either of his parents. The stories about the neighbors are cute but it had no lasting feeling.

    Audio Books: (Complete) 
    Out of Abaton, Book 1: The Wooden Prince The Best Man




    1. Out of Abaton, Book 1 (Library Edition): The Wooden Prince by John Claude Bemis.  I enjoyed the special effects -- sound effects and background music that made it even better for car listening. It suffered a bit because I only listen to audio books while driving, so it takes me forever to finish and in this case I had to recheck it out of the library. But after a slow start the middle and especially the end kept me interested.
    2. Raymie Nightingale by Kate DiCamillo. The narrator made good use of her voice in this audio -- all three children were easily distinguished by sound alone, and their accents were more southern than the narration. Even the adults were distinguished, although all the old people sounded alike at the home. I enjoyed it. 
    3. The Best Manby Richard Peck. Another narrator who easily kept all the characters distinct. The story itself was fine, but the characters all seemed a bit cliched, especially the girls. Actually even the boys were rather unsurprising. The only surprise was the amount of postering the kids put up with from their British classmate.
    4. When the Sea Turned to Silver by Grace Lin. The narrator slowly grew on me (at first she didn't seem too excited about the story) and she had a good balance of voices for the characters and emotion in the narration. However, the story itself seems to be about two children who spend the book trying to help the evil overlord destroy the world, which doesn't really seem like a good plan. They mean well, but that wouldn't mean much to the thousands of lives they are comfortable with destroying.
    5. The Inquisitor’s Tale: Or, the Three Magical Children and Their Holy Dog by Adam Gidwitz. This one really didn't work for me. I found the pace excruciatingly slow, and disliked most of the varied narrators. I also (maybe helped by the mismatch of audio to me) found the children flatly unbelievable, and found the wavering historical tone annoying and condescending. I was glad to reach the end of this. I know it's been acclaimed by all, but I'm not getting it.

    Completed: 49 /a lot

No comments: