
The poems were good. P noticed alliteration and we liked some of the false rhymes and the imagery often spun into delicious territory. The facts on opposite pages let P get his curmudgeonly feet dry of the poetry. But no single poem really called to me. The moon's progress across the pages delighted me, although I initially mistook it for the setting sun, which didn't make sense at all (east?). It's my favorite poetry book of the group so far, but I'm hoping for more. I think the illustrations set the mood more than the poems do, and the science facts add a lot. I see why it won a Newbery Honor. B
I think the Amazon link benefits the Cybils group, but I doubt it will ever get clicked. I have a very private blog.
No comments:
Post a Comment